The Block Island Times

Historic Surf Hotel will reopen this summer

By Pippa Jack | Apr 04, 2012

The owners of the landmark Surf Hotel on Block Island's Old Harbor waterfront announced this week that, five years after closing the doors and putting the grand Victorian building up for sale, it will reopen for business July 4 under new management.

“The Surf has remained empty for too long," said Barbara and Stanley Nyzio and Lorraine Cyr in a joint statement. "Now we have a plan that will get the hotel open and bring our guests back.”

The three were speaking on behalf of their mother, Beatrice Cyr, and their late father, Ulric Cyr, they said. The Cyr family ran the hotel, built in 1876, for 50 years. It attracted generations of guests who loved it for its family atmosphere, beach-side location, reasonable room rates and for the Cyr family dogs, Cavalier King Charles spaniels that were always present in the hotel's lobby.

The family closed up shop in 2007, saying the business had become too much work as they got older. They retain ownership under the name Ulbe LLC, land records show.

The 11,500-square-foot building sits atop a seawall at the southernmost end of three-mile Crescent Beach. It boasts four stories, gingerbread trim and a 1,000-square-foot deck overlooking downtown Old Harbor and the Atlantic Ocean.

Inside, it remains much as the Cyrs ran it. It is filled with old artifacts, from paintings and plates hanging on the walls to an old china doll and a stuffed eagle perched over the reception desk.

Originally going for $12 million in a joint listing by Sullivan Real Estate and Block Island Realty, the Surf's price had dropped to $6 million by last month.

The opening was made possible by a management agreement with a family experienced in renovating and operating similar resorts, Paul and Joan Nedovich of Moodus, Connecticut, and their daughters Heather Rasemus and Kimberly Afonso. The Nedovich family approached the Cyrs just three weeks ago, according to a joint statement. They were swiftly engaged by the Cyrs to oversee all of the improvements necessary to reopen the hotel and to manage operations for them.

The Cyrs have now granted an option to purchase the Surf to the Nedovich daughters for an undisclosed amount.

The hotel almost found a buyer last year, but developer Joe Vita pulled out in February 2011, citing problems getting financing. Otherwise, it has sat empty on the corner of Water and Dodge streets, attracting the curiosity of visitors and the concern of town officials worried it could become a fire risk.

“Through these last years, we've spoken to and negotiated with many who wanted to buy the Surf — some had realistic plans and others did not," said Lorraine Cyr. She added that she is confidant that the Nedovich family will operate the hotel "like our family operated.”

The July 4 opening date is "ambitious," acknowledged the Cyr family, "but really important.”

“We are probably crazy for taking this on at this late date," said Paul Nedovich, "but we have been there, done that before, and we have a high level of confidence we can pull this off. We will need good luck, and lots of cooperation from many people, to get this opened by the Cyrs' deadline.”

The Nedovich family has been renovating and operating resorts owned by them and for others since 1969 in seven states from New Hampshire to Florida to Missouri. Paul Nedovich will devote his primary attention between now and the opening to identifying all of the significant applicable regulatory requirements that must be satisfied to bring the Surf Hotel up to code in order to open. Rasemus and Afonso, who will be primarily responsible for managing the hotel once it opens, are relocating to Block Island within a few weeks to focus on the hotel's physical state. Beatrice and Lorraine Cyr and Barbara Nyzio say they are quickly wrapping up their Florida vacation to get back to Block Island and help.


Comments (12)
Posted by: Martha Ball | Apr 04, 2012 16:03

Wonderful news!!

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Jean Taber | Apr 04, 2012 17:18

This is the best news ever. We should all be grateful to the people who are taking the risk and putting it all on the line. Also to the Cyr's, who kept the place in good shape even when no revenue was coming in. Perhaps they could find ways for us to volunteer to help in order to meet that deadline!

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Anne Hunter | Apr 04, 2012 21:22

I'm so excited!  I'd love to know how to get a reservation.  I've missed  BI so much.

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Suzanne D Cotter | Apr 04, 2012 22:45

THAT'S WONDERFUL NEWS!!  The Cyrs have done a terrific job of keeping the Surf in good shape while seeking a buyer!!  I hope this brings new life to the front street of Block Island (and a successful buyer for the Cyrs!)!!!

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Fran Huggard Migliaccio | Apr 05, 2012 10:12

That is very exciting news! I am so happy that good, qualified are willing to take on such a project, and I wish them, and the Cyrs, all the best!

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Linda Spak | Apr 05, 2012 10:37

I am so pleased for eveyone. It's a beautiful building with great spirit. I agree with Jean and hope all involved will put out a call for volunteers. I'd be honored to help.

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Michael OBrien | Apr 06, 2012 21:55

This is such wonderful news. I am glad Lorraine is still involved and I hope they manage to keep the same charm and spirit of the place although that would be expecting to much...times change but let's just hope it does not have to at the Surf. Hope they contact all the old regulars to let them know the doors are open!

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Jean M Nichols | Apr 07, 2012 00:57

Such exciting can we get a reservation and be there this summer to spend quality, peaceful time with friends from near and afar. Agree with Michael and hope we get contacted so we can all be back where time can be as it was and a blissful place can be enjoyed by all!!

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Carol Norton | Apr 09, 2012 12:01

THE BEST news! Good luck to the Cyr's, Nyzio's and the Nedovich family.

Wish we could be there to help. Count us in for September! Block Island's front door will once again be sparkling with happy faces filling the Surf's porches. I can hardly wait to be one of them.

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Judith B Govoni | Apr 10, 2012 19:35

What great news!  We haven't been to the island since the Surf closed.  Can't wait to go back!  How do we get reservations?

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Spencer Liles | Apr 15, 2012 23:59

This is awesome news for the Cyr family and for everyone!!!  Can't wait to fall asleep to the sound of the ocean again.

Flag as inappropriate

Posted by: Nancy & Lawrence Mizen | Apr 16, 2012 00:23

Unbelieveable!  A dream come true!  It's better than winning the lottery!  Thanks so much to the Cyr family (We miss Ulric!) & the Nedovich family, whom we're excited to meet.  Add our name to the list of those waiting to make reservations!  A bygone era returns!  Elation!

Nancy & Larry Mizen

Flag as inappropriate

If you wish to comment, please login.